VioletPixel

Justin Michael's notions and miscellanea

πŸ™‰ Siri Recap Gets Closer to a Release that Shouldn't Happen

Juli Clover has been using the Siri Recap beta for the last two weeks:

It's a privacy-forward way of tracking what's going on around you, but after two weeks of testing, it's clear that the privacy safeguards limit its usefulness. Overly brief summaries, lack of speaker labeling, and no original audio to compare against make β€ŒSiriβ€Œ Recap unreliable.

Before I get into my experience, I want to make it clear that β€ŒSiriβ€Œ Recap is a beta feature in beta software. It hasn't been released yet, Apple hasn't finished refining it, and it won't be available to the public until watchOS 27.3 launches in December. Still, the bones are in place. Some of the issues I encountered could improve before release, but others are the result of the way it's built.

Purely from a functionality perspective, Juli's experience is worse than I expected, even for a beta. It baffles me that Apple would risk significant damage to their privacy-focused brand image on a feature with so little actual utility. The juice really isn't worth the squeeze with this feature.

Apple shouldn't release Siri Recap. Not in December. Not ever.

Quick reactions:
Nuanced reactions: contact me

Viewable in Any Browser Valid HTML Valid CSS Atom Valid Debian Powered Powered by PHP Made on a Mac Planned in Things Built with Nova Written in Bear Pixelmator Pro Kagi: Humanize the Web Safari Netscape Power! Rivian